How to Start Your Action Figure Collection

If you’re new to collecting action figures or you’ve just started collecting hopefully this short guide will help you from making most of the common mistakes others make and avoid the pitfalls.

It will help you decide:

  • what to collect
  • your niche
  • which to collect
  • and what to buy
  • whether to collect ‘em all

Although most of this information is for action figure collectors it can just as easily be used for collecting anything.

Ok, ready?

Then let’s get started.

First ask yourself...

Why do I want to collect action figures?

Is it:

  • For financial gain
  • For enjoyment

Most people collect for one of these two reasons and your answer to this question will affect virtually every decision you make from now on.

So, think long and hard before answering.

Ok, now let’s move on…

If your primary goal is to make money then to read up on eBbay and other auction sites, how to buy and sell action figures, valuing and grading your action figures, and storing your action figures.

If on the other hand you collect for the pure fun and enjoyment of collecting, then great, this report will help you get started and keep your costs down.

Now let’s get on with starting your collection.

But wait, first...

What Should You Collect?

How do you decide:

  • What's best to collect?
  • What to buy?
  • Where to get them?
  • How to save money?

Hmm, good questions.

Let me help you answer them.

You have a lot of choices ahead of you so it is best to start with a clear, predetermined idea of what you want before doing anything else.

Often when I ask people what they collect, They answer “action figures”.

But when I ask, what sort?

I get a blank look.

I think it's important to focus your time, money, and attention on one subject, one niche, initially otherwise you will end up wasting a lot of time, money and energy.


Because if you don’t focus your collection you’ll end up with an assortment of nice looking action figures but NOT a collection.

Without this central theme or common thread your collection will be nothing more than a handful of toys.

But with a common theme your collection will gel together as one and look a lot more impressive.

If you're a card collector decide WHAT cards you want to collect? trading cards, card games, science fiction, cartoon, TV, Star Wars, Star Trek, Fire engines.....

If you're a stamp collector WHAT stamps do you want to collect? animals, trains, Thai, French, 1800's, planes, George Washington, civil war....

If you're a coin collector WHAT coins do you want to collect? Gold, silver, bronze, Roman, Greek, British, American Civil War......

If you're an action figure collector WHAT action figures? Movies, Star Wars, wrestling, baseball, cartoons, TV, Simpsons, PC Game figures......

Get the picture?

OK, so how do you decide?

Before we start get a pen and some paper, a cup of coffee, tea (or a beer if you prefer).

Now you're ready for some brainstorming.

Why You Need To Choose A Niche?

Think about the following questions:

  • What movies do you like?
  • Who is your favourite movie star?
  • What sports do you like?
  • What are your favourite teams?
  • Who is your favourite baseball star?
  • What are your favourite TV programs?
  • What cartoons do you like?
  • Do you like Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, or Fanatsy?

Write down your answers and build a list of subjects that you like and enjoy watching, reading about, or playing.

Make sure they're things you really like or enjoy, things that grab your imagination and are close to your heart.

Something you are passionate about and care about.

Because there's nothing worse than collecting something that you have no passion for.

That becomes a business, or worse still WORK.

I know some people who collect purely for monetary reasons and they have no enthusiasm for it and as a result they get no pleasure from their collections.

Now take a look at your list and choose between 1 to 3 unrelated subjects.



  • If one is to narrow (more on this in a minute) you can start on one of your other choices.
  • To give your collection, and you, some variety.

Good, now:

How To Choose Your Niche?

Ok, so what's a niche?

A niche is like a sub-topic of a larger topic, it is more concentrated and specialist.

For example a main topic or subject in action figure collections, and probably one of the most popular, would be Star Wars figures.

But that is a HUGE market, so a niche here would be R2D2 figures or Darth Vader.

Get the idea?

Personally though I would not recommend anyone starting a collection based on Star Wars figures for the same reasons I NEVER stocked any in my shops or sold them on my website.

  • The market is too big.
  • There are too many.
  • The competition is fierce.
  • The market is saturated.

But, that said if your mind's set on collecting Star Wars figures then choose your niche carefully.

Make sure it's small enough to be affordable and collectable.

For example you could specialize in collecting Luke Skywalker figures or figures from any one of the movies (although this topic is probably still a bit too broad).

Another good example of choosing a niche would be instead of collecting McFarlane's Baseball figures choose your favourite team or a couple of teams or players, and stick with them.

You'll be thankful you did because there is nothing worse than having all the figures in set or series "except for...".

It leaves you feeling incomplete and with a need to fill the space.

Trust me, it can get very frustrating.

The main objective of this exercise is to find a niche that is tight enough to enable you to:

  • build your collection
  • complete each release/series
  • keep costs down
  • increase your enjoyment and satisfaction
  • take pride in your collection
  • give your collection uniformity
  • build on a theme

So, in conclusion take your time in deciding on your niche now, then stick with it. If you find it's too narrow a niche you can always broaden it later or move onto one of your other choices.

But by being selective in choosing your niche now you will get more enjoyment and satisfaction out of your collection and probably save time and money later.

OK, so you've chosen your subject and your niche.

What now?

Now you need to decide:

Should You Collect ‘em All?

You are probably thinking, "Of course I do"

But wait a minute...

...and think it through before committing yourself.

This decision will greatly influence how much you are going to spend on your collection and it will give you a better focus on what to look out for.

Most lines of action figures include regular figures, variant figures, chase figures, collectors editions, limited editions and exclusives etc.

Each "level" of rarity becomes more expensive than the previous level. The cheapest being the regular figures but at the same time these are the ones that are the most common and mass produced so rarely have any secondary value.

Again it is important to decide now because if you change your mind later you may have a hard time getting some of the figures you've missed.

Not sure what a variant, chase, or exclusive figure is?

Then read my "What Is A Variant Figure Report" article.

Good, almost done.

Should You Buy New Or Secondhand?

  • Carded or uncarded?
  • Mint, near mint or...?
  • Do you want to keep them boxed?
  • Or display them?

Again these are all these decisions that will affect the final price you will have to pay for your figures so it's best to decide now.

If you're a budget collector then your best bet would be to go for second-hand figures and save buying the new ones for special figures or ones that you particularly like.

If you're into customizing your figures then second-hand figures is also an obvious choice. I discuss the topic of customizing your figures in greater detail on Customizing Action Figures.

But if you have the spare cash and want your figures in pristine condition to display then new figures is the way to go.

But if you're a perfectionist and wish to ensure they stay in absolute mint condition and retain their value you will probably want to buy two of each.


Many purist collectors will often opt to purchase two figures so they can keep one carded and in Mint condition and open the other to display.

Which you decide to do will of course depend on how much money you can afford to spend on your hobby, and the actual value of the figure.

Generally second-hand non-mint figures have very little to no value whereas Gem-Mint carded figures will often increase in value over time, particular the variant figures or limited production runs.

My personal recommendation would be to keep any chase, variant, exclusive or Super Chase figures carded or buy two if you want to display one.

This is what I usually do, or I buy a good condition second-hand figure for display and a carded one to be kept.

Many toy stores or hobby shops will sell there own ex-display figures or items with damaged cards at a cheaper price.

Make sure if you're putting any on display, particularly any rarer ones, that they are displayed and protected properly.

Beware of massively overproduced mass market figures, as these, even in Gem Mint Carded condition are unlikely to increase in value for a long time.

I enjoy having most of my figures on display and I used to have a huge diorama of a wilderness landscape with dragons and monsters displayed that looked awesome and was hugely popular.


I almost forgot...

What Scale?

This is another important choice because there are numerous sizes and scales from 1:26 to 1:1, or from 3 inch figures to life size figures.

Try to stick to the same scale.

There's nothing worse than having a Frodo Baggins who's bigger than the Balrog after all, is there.

OK, that's it for now.

Have fun.

Now that we've sorted out exactly what you're going to collect, lets look at...

Taking Care of Your Action Figures

[?] Subscribe To This Site

Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to My MSN
Subscribe with Bloglines

How to Grade an Action Figure


How to Grade an Action Figure

ONLY $2.99!




How to Collect Action Figures

How to Grade Your
Action Figures

Action Figures Wanted


Video Reviews

Tutorials & Articles

Customs Corner


Play Asia
Toys + Figures


Entertainment Earth

McFarlane Toys


Comic Cons

Q & A


NFL Football

MLB Baseball

NBA Basketball

NHL Hockey

Wrestling Figures

MMA Mixed Martial
Arts Figures






Movie Figures


Video Game

TV Figures


Gashapon figures

Disney Figures

Marvel Comic Figures

DC Comic Figures

Military Figures

Fantasy Figures

Music Figures

Urban Vinyl




Contact Me

About Me

Privacy Policy

Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape

mcfarlanes-figures Privacy Policy © Copyright and Copy Colin Dorman 2008

All trademarks and registered trademarks, whether or not so identified, are acknowledged to be the property of their respective owners. The use of a trademark does not imply that such use has been authorised, endorsed or sponsored by the trademark owner.